Good fit. Just the waist is a litttllleeee too big. I am 5’8 180 and yes they are super stretchy.

Beautiful in person, much different than what I would normally order. These shorts have a lot of stretch, much more than what I thought!! Definitely could’ve sized down- I think I may send these back and order the 11s for slightly tighter fit. Or maybe they’ll shrink when I wash them.. The bottoms of the shorts (hem area) didn’t fit to my leg as I was expecting so that was the only thing off-putting. I am 5’2, 165lbs; 43-34-43, fuller thighs!